The Ugly Truth About Shame, Embarrassment, and Guilt

Sharing is Caring!
  • 213
  • 6


The mere sound of the word conjures feelings of embarrassment and withdrawal. And even though it’s a normal feeling, it never gets easier–not even with age.

Unfortunately, many times we tend to interchange shame, embarrassment, and guilt thinking all three are the same.

Pin it for later!

The Ugly Truth About Shame, Embarrassment, and Guilt text with a woman's back showing as she is looking at the ocean.

In reality, there is some overlap, but overall, they are very different.

Sadly, we feel shame, embarrassment, and guilt about the dumbest things that are really just a mistake. Perhaps a very embarrassing mistake but one nonetheless. Sadly, we don’t know how to separate the truth.

The truth about shame is that it is sneaky, destructive, and lurks in all of us waiting to permeate our souls if we let it. Let me tell you how it almost took me down.

Related: How to Quickly Overcome a Failure or Loss


The Christmas Tree Debacle (A Huge Embarrassment)

A few weeks ago I destroyed killed our Christmas tree. Who even does that? 

It was purely by accident, but I still felt an enormous amount of shame and embarrassment over the whole incident.

I’m trying to laugh now, but it wasn’t so funny a couple of weeks ago.

Here’s what happened…We had a strand of lights on the tree that didn’t work so I tried to “fix it.” Unfortunately, that  “one” strand was connected to many other strands in the tree. Actually, it was connected to the whole middle section.

Sadly, most of the Christmas tree went dark due to my “fixing” it. The top and bottom of the tree were lit, while the middle section quietly stayed silent and mocked me as I stood in horror.

After another hour of “fixing” the tree, I gave up. I could no longer stand to look at my mess. There was no hiding this from my husband and kids.

In a fit of despair, I hauled the prickly green mess out to the alley and hid it behind a bush near our trashcans.

I would put it in the trash receptacle on trash day.


Later that night my husband asked about the tree. It was kinda obvious it was missing. Unfortuantely, I was forced back out to the trashcans because he insisted we fix it. Well…he fix it.

What he really meant was we are going to keep the stupid-looking tree for the next ten years no matter what.

More shame and embarrassment.

In my mind, we now had a six-foot, green blob whose middle section was missing lights due to my genius tree hacking.  Furthermore, I am going to have to deal with this every year I pull out the tree, unzip the bag, and expose the lightless, furry limbs.

I could already feel the tree mocking me for the unforeseeable future.

Future shame, embarrassment, and guilt. Oh yay.

Related: 11 Revealing Clues You Are a Hot Mess Mom

The Ugly Truth About Shame overlay. A woman with red hair holding her hand over mouth.

Shame and Embarrassment. What’s the Difference?

Like me, you may have the same feelings come over you when you make a mistake. Do you feel shame, embarrassment, or guilt?

The tree debacle was clearly a mistake, but mentally it was hard to separate an embarrassing mistake from real shame and guilt.

In reality, all three are different.

Embarrassment is an uncomfortable feeling that may undermine the image of who we wish others to perceive us to be. It includes actions that make us look or feel awkward, funny-looking, or stupid.

In my case, I didn’t want to look like the ding-dong who destroyed the Christmas tree. And be reminded of it year after year…

In contrast, shame goes much deeper.

The truth about shame is that it is associated with moral character, not social character or image. Shame is how we deal with something that we have done wrong.

Sounds like guilt, right? Not exactly. Let me explain.

Estranged: Finding Hope When Your Family Falls Apart book with a single tree on the cover

 Purchase your ebook or paperback on Amazon or at your favorite digital store. 

The Difference Between Shame and Guilt

Shame says, “I am bad” whereas guilt says, “I did something bad.” Big difference. 

The truth about shame is that it carries the fear of being exposed, rejected, or humiliated for behaviors such as addictions, aggression, or abuse; things that are generally found morally wrong by society. Shame makes you think you can’t change. That you are fundamentally flawed as a person. Powerless.

On the other hand, the Bible says guilt or “godly sorrow” exists to help us. It leads us to repentance and growth. This kind of guilt is healthy because it is motivated by love. There is a motivation to restore what has been broken. A sense of power to make things right. 

2 Corinthians 7:10 says, “For godly grief produces a repentance that leads to salvation without regret, whereas worldly grief produces death” (ESV).

Guilt is a sign of emotional health. Conversely, shame is not. Shame keeps us stuck in self; it’s all about me. In fact, it hides, blames, and pouts. 

Related:5 Awesome Hacks to Get Rid of Self Pity Once and For All

Woman sitting down crossed leg leaning over with head in her hands. The truth about shame and guilt overlay.The Real Truth About Shame

Do you know the real truth about shame?

Shame is a choice. Since we all have shame (sinned) at one time or another, it is good to learn how to deal with it in a healthy way. One of the best ways is to turn to Jesus for help. He came so we didn’t have to live in shame. Ask Him for the power to change your mindset. To move out of self and into love.

People who stay stuck in shame choose not to take ownership of their mistakes and therefore wallow in self. People who choose to feel sorrow or guilt own their mistakes, make amends and change. And those who feel embarrassed because of a mistake…choose to forgive themselves, learn from it, and move on.

And maybe even laugh about it!

Related: Why Laughter In Marriage Is Important

Letting Go of Shame

If you are feeling upset about a situation, ask yourself if it is shame, embarrassment, or guilt. Then you can deal with it appropriately.

If you are feeling genuine shame. it is time to explore your feelings. Ask why you feel this way. One of the ways I mentally work through shameful feelings is to use self-talk. It helps me separate the truth from the lies.

Related: Positive Self-Talk: Powerful Ways to Use Scripture

Psychology Today has some good suggestions on how to silence the shame in your life. Check it out if you need a starting point.

God knows your situation. Ask Him to reveal where you need to get set free. The most important thing you can do is talk to someone. Bring it out in the open.

If you need help, go to a counselor or pastor. There is no shame in doing that. In fact, it is the healthiest thing to do when you are stuck and can’t unravel your situation.

You don’t have to live a life full of shame. Jesus came to set you free from this kind of thinking.

Isaiah 54:4 says, “Fear not, for you will not be ashamed; be not confounded, for you will not be disgraced; for you will forget the shame of your youth, and the reproach of your widowhood you will remember no more” (ESV).

The Ugly Truth About Shame Embarrassment, and Guilt overlay with flowers in the background.

Do You Have Family Problems? There is Help!

Are you experiencing family problems or even estranged? Are you feeling shame, anger, or rejection? Check out my book Estranged: Finding Hope When Your Family Falls Apart on Amazon or at your favorite digital store. 

This book not only talks about my seven-year estrangement from my Christian family, but it also gives solid tips to help you with your family problems. Break free from your pain. Allow God to heal you no matter what has happened in your family of origin. There is hope when your family falls apart.

Estranged: Finding Hope When Your Family Falls Apart book with a single tree on the book


Creating Family Memories Book

Get Creating Family Memories. This book will help you manage your family in a way that allows more time to be intentional with your kids.  It includes a schedule too. You can get it at your favorite bookstore.

A farm scene with a farmhouse upside down sitting on a grass field with a lake in the background.

Join Christian Family Living Facebook Group

Continue the conversation on Facebook and join the group Christian Family Living. This is a place for Christian women to share their experiences and get helpful tools to navigate the Christian life. We love to laugh, cry, and encourage each other to live out our faith one day at a time.

Check Out Pinterest

For Parenting Tips, Crafts, Baby Care, Pre-School, Teens, Family Activities, And Much More!

Julie Plagens


  1. Olawunmi on February 7, 2020 at 7:17 am

    “What he really meant was we are going to keep the stupid-looking tree for the next ten years no matter what” I found this line hilarious 😀 I like how you have been able to use a practical life example to explain the differences between these words. Thanks for this explicit explanation, I have learnt alot.

  2. Boma on February 7, 2020 at 2:20 am

    And we can’t let these things fester and pollute our minds! Thanks for sharing. Many blessings to you!

  3. Marina on January 10, 2020 at 5:16 pm

    What a great post! For me usually if it’s a silly situation, I feel embarrassed at first, and then a couple of days, weeks, months later, I laugh about it. After a while, it doesn’t seem like such a big deal as it did when it happened!

Leave a Comment